A Level Critical Thinking OCR
Full course content, a smart revision plan and instant past paper feedback for A Level Critical Thinking OCR.
Start revising this course →Content Overview
40 topics in 4 modules
☑️ Module: Understanding Argument Structure 10 topics
- Identifying claims, reasons, and conclusions
- The nature of assumptions
- Recognising an argument
- Distinguishing between simple and complex arguments
- Evaluating analogy in arguments
- Understanding cause and effect reasoning
- Appreciating the role of context in argument interpretation
- Dealing with hypothetical reasoning
- Reasoning based on correlations and samples
- Intricacies of inductive reasoning
☑️ Module: Evaluating Argument Credibility 10 topics
- The impact of language in argument presentation
- Importance and role of evidence in arguments
- Understanding types of evidence
- Assessing evidence quality
- The role of expertise in argument credibility
- Evaluating the reliability of sources
- Role of bias and vested interest in arguments
- Argument credibility versus logical strength
- Corroboration, consistency, and contradiction in argument analysis
- The fine line between unsubstantiated claims and valid assumptions
☑️ Module: Challenges in Critical Reasoning 10 topics
- Logical fallacies and their role in reasoning
- Assessing generalisation strength
- Heart of induction: strength versus soundness
- Issues of relevance in argument analysis
- Analysing appeals to emotion, authority, and popularity
- Omissions and their implication in reasoning
- Contextual relevance and its impact on argument quality
- Distinguishing between fact and opinion
- The trap of circular reasoning
- Evasiveness and ambiguity in arguments
☑️ Module: Constructing Arguments 10 topics
- Elements of sound argument construction
- The role of clear and precise language
- Coherence and validity in argument construction
- Incorporating assumptions in arguments
- Provision of relevant reasons and evidence
- Counter-argument handling
- Building argument upon reliable data
- Keeping track of argument focus
- Argument conciseness and punch
- Striking a balance between emotion and logic in arguments
A Level Critical Thinking OCR Revision Content
Take a look at the written content available for this course. Practice-question availability may vary.
A Level Critical Thinking OCR - Module: Understanding Argument Structure - Identifying claims, reasons, and conclusions Content Preview
Module: Understanding Argument Structure
Identifying claims, reasons, and conclusions
Understanding Argument Structure
Arguments play a critical role in reasoning. They present a set of claims and reasons that form the basis of concluding a line of thought.
Identifying Claims
- A claim is a statement or assertion that is open to challenge. It's the point an arguer is trying to make.
- A claim could be factual, value-oriented, or a policy recommendation. They essentially set the stage for the argument.
- Look out for subjective statements or opinions and interpret them as potential claims.
- Words like 'believe', 'should', 'ought to', 'must', etc., often precede claims.
- Always look to differentiate claims from established facts.
Identifying Reasons
- Reasons are statements provided to justify or back up a claim.
- Main and supporting points in any argument are often reasons.
- They sometimes begin with transitional words like because, since, for, in that, as shown by, and so on.
- Reasons are necessary to draw a conclusion from a claim and often provide evidence towards the claim.
Identifying Conclusions
- A conclusion is a claim that has been reached by a process of reasoning.
- Remember, conclusions are usually the main point that the author wants to convince the reader of.
- These can often be recognised by words like 'therefore', 'thus', 'hence', 'so', 'in conclusion', 'it follows that', and so on.
- Conclusions may not always appear at the end of an argument. Sometimes, they are stated at the beginning or interspersed throughout the argument.
- Be sure to differentiate between intermediate conclusions (support other conclusions) and main conclusions (aim of the argument).
Connecting Claims, Reasons, and Conclusions
- An argument can be seen as a structure with claims supported by reasons, leading to a conclusion.
- The authors often use indicators to help readers identify claims, reasons, and conclusions.
- Note that not all statements in an argument will be a part of claims, reasons, or conclusions. Look out for evidence, examples, elaborations, clarifications, and other such elements.
- Recognising the structure and flow of the argument is crucial to understanding the logic and criticism behind the argument.
- Critical thinking involves not only identifying these elements but also examining the credibility and relevance of reasons and the soundness of the overall argument.
Question: Identify the claim, reason, and conclusion in the following statement: "Because fast food is high in fat and low in nutritional value, it is not healthy to consume on a regular basis; therefore, it can be harmful to one's health if consumed frequently."
Unlock instant, personalised feedback
Sign up to Adapt to practise the exam questions available for this course with instant, personalised feedback.
Start revising this course →Try Adapt now
Add this exact course and build your personalised revision plan.